Review: This is What Happy Looks Like

Author: Jennifer E. Smith
Date of Publication: April 2, 2013
Pages: 416
Source:Library

If fate sent you an email, would you answer?

When teenage movie star Graham Larkin accidentally sends small town girl Ellie O'Neill an email about his pet pig, the two seventeen-year-olds strike up a witty and unforgettable correspondence, discussing everything under the sun, except for their names or backgrounds.

Then Graham finds out that Ellie's Maine hometown is the perfect location for his latest film, and he decides to take their relationship from online to in-person. But can a star as famous as Graham really start a relationship with an ordinary girl like Ellie? And why does Ellie want to avoid the media's spotlight at all costs?



Review:
I hate to be the downer, especially with such an anticipated book, but what can I do; I'm disappointed.

I had my first taste of Jennifer E. Smith's writing in her debut novel, The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight, which I enjoyed and it earned a few more brownie points as John Green enjoyed and recommended it too. (DFTBA!) As a result, I had expectations for this book. Nothing too extravagant, just a genuine belief that Smith would come though.

One of the criticisms for her debut was the short length but with This is What Happy Looks Like, I felt the biggest problem was the length. It was too long. The plot, story and characters were not round or developed enough to last 400 pages. After the first 100 pages the story hit a snag and it was a downward spiral from there. There was no real momentum driving the plot forward, there was one storyline and it took 400 pages to complete it.

First the plot. It is simple; girl meets boy, boy is a superstar and girl has a past. It sounds great for a fun, no thought required read, but sometimes even those need a little bit of thought or else they feel bland; uninteresting. That's what happened with this one. I think Smith tried to use the cliche, as she did with her debut and really spin a story that doesn't feel like it. But it felt cliche, it felt unrealistic and that's a problem with contemporary. I expect a little bit of realism even if it's fiction and a lot of wishful thinking.

As for the characters, loved Graham and Ellie for the first 100 pages and then they didn't grow enough for me to continue to like them. Graham was too perfect to a fault. He was too "not into the scene", too "complete nice guy" which ended up reducing the amount of depth one saw in his personality. As for Ellie, I didn't find her interesting at all and I don't know what more to say. I didn't connect with her, I didn't care what happened to her.

Overall, it really is a cute concept and story but in my opinion it's good if you're looking for something with no real thought. It's light, fun, summery. I wish there was more depth and more plot but it is what it is and many have enjoyed it. The question is, is this one for you? It wasn't for me.

-MARI

 

10 comments:

  1. Hm. It's a shame to hear that, but yeah, 400 pages seems very, very long for a YA contemp romance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is. I'm hoping Smith's next book will find the sweet spot between Statistical Probability and This is What Happy Looks Like, in length.

      -Mari

      Delete
  2. This was not my favorite of her books -- I liked Statistical Probability more, and also The Comeback Season. I have high hopes for The Geography of You and Me!

    Thanks so much for stopping by! Jen @ YA Romantics

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same the Statistical Probability was just right, IMO. I haven't read any of her other books but I plan too.

      -Mari

      Delete
  3. I had such high expectations for this one! Sounds like it's a bit boring though. I'll probably still give it a read at some point, but I'll keep in mind that the book has a slow pace!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As did I, and it starts our really cute and interesting but the slow pace didn't do much to capture or keep my attention.

      Good luck with this one, I hope you enjoy it more.

      -Mari

      Delete
  4. What a bummer! I'm still looking forward to checking this one out... & thanks for stopping by my blog!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should, it is really cute.

      -Mari

      Delete
  5. I have similar feelings about this one-I wanted to love it so much after seeing all the raves but it didn't thrill me either.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same, it just wasn't my cup of tea.

      -Mari

      Delete

What do you think?